杨 毅,张文瑞,陈凯伟,陈怡婷,戴晓军,龚春慧,王 鹏
南京理工大学 环境与生物工程学院,江苏 南京 210094
杨毅,张文瑞,陈凯伟,等. 金属有机框架复合材料对放射性碘的吸附机制研究进展[J].中国粉体技术,2024,30(4):151-160.
YANG Y, ZHANG W R, CHEN K W, et al. Research progress on adsorption mechanism of radioactive iodine by metal-organic framework composites[J].China Powder Science and Technology,2024,30(4):151-160.
DOI:10.13732/j.issn.1008-5548.2024.04.014
收稿日期:2024-05-07,修回日期:2024-05-22,上线日期:2024-06-25。
基金项目:国家自然科学基金项目,编号:1180050743;江苏省生态环境科研项目,编号:2022017。
第一作者简介:杨毅(1973—),男,教授,博士,江苏省“333工程”培养对象,江苏省“六大人才高峰”培养对象,博士生导师,研究方向为环境功能材料。
E-mail:yyi301@163. com。
摘要:【目的】 以金属有机框架(metal-organic framework, MOF)复合材料作为吸附剂高效吸附核电站运行、核燃料后处理、核医学过程以及核事故等所泄漏的放射性碘,研究MOF复合材料对放射性碘的吸附机制,消除环境中的放射性碘污染。【研究现状】综述了近年来 MOF 复合材料吸附放射性碘的基于化学反应、强化 MOF 空间结构和电子转移的吸附机制。MOF 中掺杂银、铜和铋金属或金属氧化物生成的 MOF 复合材料具有较大的接触面积和较多的活性位点,铋掺杂MOF复合材料对气态I2的吸附性能最优。在MOF复合材料中掺杂多孔材料能增大孔隙体积;高温热解MOF复合材料使得活性位点均匀分布并提高利用率;在 MOF复合材料中嵌合纳米复合膜或离子液体能够与吸附物充分接触,回收性和重复利用性好;改变 MOF 的金属节点或共轭同类 MOF 衍生出的 MOF 复合材料,可增强对放射性碘的物理吸附性能。MOF复合材料可以经过碳化作用增强与放射性碘的电荷转移作用,I2能以络合物的形式吸附在MOF复合材料的活性位点上。【展望】虽然对 MOF 复合材料对放射性碘的吸附机制的研究取得重要进展,但仍然面临着吸附容量小、吸附速率慢、回收利用性差及活性位点利用率低等问题。提出应进一步研究铋掺杂 MOF复合材料,探究在高温条件下对放射性碘的吸附机制,采取适当措施减少金属掺杂MOF复合材料对环境的二次污染。
关键词:金属有机框架;复合材料;衍生材料;放射性碘;吸附机制;吸附容量
Significance Radioactive iodine, generated from nuclear power plant operations, nuclear fuel reprocessing, nuclear medicine processes, and nuclear accidents, mainly exists in the form of gaseous iodine (I2).Gaseous I2 may form iodomethane (CH3I)with other volatile organic compounds and hydrocarbons in the gas stream. Once inhaled, the gaseous I2 and CH3I convert into forms such as 131I and 129I in the human body, leading to consequences such as metabolic imbalance, thyroid cancer, and leukemia after continuous accumulation. A small portion of radioactive iodine exists in the form of solid I2 and I- . Metal-organic framework (MOF) composites are often used to adsorb various forms of radioactive iodine because of their good modifiability, large adjustable pore size, and high thermal stability. Therefore, it is of great significance to thoroughly investigate the mechanisms of effective adsorption of radioactive iodine by MOF composites.
Progress The study reviews three types of adsorption mechanisms of radioactive iodine by MOF composites: chemical reaction,carrier spatial structure, and electron transfer. MOF composites doped with metals or metal oxides such as silver, copper, and bismuth have larger contact areas and more active sites. During the adsorption of radioactive iodine, these composites form compounds such as BiI3, BiOI, AgI, and CuI through chemical reactions with radioactive iodine, facilitating subsequent radionuclide solidification and other treatments. Bismuth-doped MOF composites are cost effective, low in toxicity and have the best adsorption performance for gaseous I2. Strengthening the spatial structure of MOF can improve the adsorption capacity of MOF composites for radioactive iodine. Effective methods include: doping porous materials into the MOF composites to increase the pore volume; conducting high-temperature pyrolysis to stabilize the structure, prevent collapse, and improve the uniform distribution and utilization of active sites, thus enhancing the reusability, acid resistance, and selective adsorption; integrating nanocomposite membranes or ionic liquids (ILs) with MOF composites to ensure that the adsorbent is in full contact with radioactiveiodine, which is able to facilitate the recovery and reuse of adsorbents and can yield the highest I3- adsorption; changing the metal nodes of the MOF or conjugating similar MOF to derive new MOF composites, enhancing the physical adsorption performance of radioactive iodine. In electron transfer-based adsorption mechanisms, MOF composites can be carbonized to enhance the charge transfer interactions with radioactive iodine, enabling I2 to be adsorbed in the form of charge transfer complexes at the active sites of MOF composites.
Conclusions and Prospects Although important progress has been made in the adsorption mechanisms of radioactive iodine by MOF composites, challenges such as low adsorption capacity, slow adsorption rate, poor recyclability, and low utilization of active sites still exist. To improve the performance of MOF composites for radioiodine adsorption, further studies are needed on bismuth-doped MOF composites to achieve higher adsorption capacity for gaseous I2 through a combination of chemical adsorption and physical adsorption. Given that the water vapor temperature in nuclear fuel reprocessing can reach up to 150 °C, it is essential to investigate the adsorption mechanisms of the MOF composites under high-temperature conditions. Since the study of non-radioactive 127I cannot reflect the radiation resistance of MOF composites, the adsorption performance of MOF composites under actual irradiation should be explored. In addition, while enhancing the stability and adsorption performance of metaldoped MOF composites, it is of great importance to minimize the secondary pollution caused by them.
Keywords:metal-organic framework; composites; derived materials; radioactive iodine; adsorption mechanism; adsorption capacity
[1]BRUDECKI K, KOWALSKA A, ZAGRODZKI P, et al. Measurement of 131I activity in thyroid of nuclear medical staff and internal dose assessment in a Polish nuclear medical hospital [J].Radiation and Environmental Biophysics,2017,56(1):19-26.
[2]HUVE J, RYZHIKOV A, NOUALI H, et al. Porous sorbents for the capture of radioactive iodine compounds: a review [J].Royal Society of Chemistry Advances,2018,8(51):29248-29273.
[3]李智颖,顾傲天,杨毅. 锌铜多孔碳复合材料制备及其吸附碘研究[J].南京理工大学学报(自然科学版),2023,47(3):404-411.
LI Z Y, GU A T, YANG Y. Preparation and iodine adsorption properties of zinc-copper porous carbon materials[J].Journal of Nanjing University of Science and Technology (Natural Science Edition),2023,47(3):404-411.
[4]唐安宇,何曼丽,陈九玉,等. 基于Cu-BTC骨架的Cu2O-CuO复合材料的制备及吸其附性能 [J].中国粉体技术,2021,27(3):80-88.
TANG A Y, HE M L, CHEN J Y, et al. Preparation and its adsorption properties of Cu2O-CuO composite material based on Cu-BTC framework [J].China Powder Science and Technology,2021,27(3):80-88.
[5]TESFAY REDA A, ZHANG D X, XU X Y, et al. Highly stable iodine capture by pillared montmorillonite functionalized Bi2O3@g-C3N4 nanosheets [J].Separation and Purification Technology,2022,292:120994.
[6]SUN H X, YANG B L, LI A. Biomass derived porous carbon for efficient capture of carbon dioxide, organic contaminants and volatile iodine with exceptionally high uptake [J].Chemical Engineering Journal,2019,372:65-73.
[7]DING Y, FAN W J, XIAN Q, et al. Capture of iodine gas by Bi0 modified silica with different morphologies: influence of pore characteristic on the stable and unstable forms of adsorption [J].Chemical Engineering Journal,2023,451:138887.
[8]SCOTT S M, HU T, YAO T K, et al. Graphene-based sorbents for iodine-129 capture and sequestration [J].Carbon,2015,90:1-8.
[9]HAN T T, WANG L N, POTGIETER J H. ZIF-11 derived nanoporous carbons with ultrahigh uptakes for capture and reversible storage of volatile iodine [J].Journal of Solid State Chemistry,2020,282:121108.
[10]GU Y F, WU Y N, LI L C, et al. Controllable modular growth of hierarchical MOF-on-MOF architectures [J].Angewandte Chemie (International Edition in English),,2017,56(49):15658-15662.
[11]张晨飞,马景灵,贾兴良,等. 基于双金属MOFs衍生的NiCo/NC多孔碳催化材料的电化学性能研究[J].陶瓷学报,2023,44(1):115-123. ZHANG C F, MA J L, JIA X L, et al. Electrochemical activity of NiCo/NC porous carbon catalytic materials derived from bimetallic MOFs [J].Journal of Ceramics,2023,44(1):115-123.
[12]MA Y D, JIANG X F, LIU Z M, et al. Combining hierarchical pores and unsaturated sites into Quasi-MIL-125(Ti) for ultra-fast and efficient adsorption of cationic dyes [J].Polyhedron,2023,239:116430.
[13]TANG Y Z, HUANG H L, LI J, et al. IL-induced formation of dynamic complex iodide anions in IL@MOF composites for efficient iodine capture [J].Journal of Materials Chemistry A,2019,7(31):18324-18329.
[14]顾傲天,谭伟洋,李智颖,等. Ag-MMOFs复合材料的制备及其对硝基苯酚的降解作用[J].中国粉体技术,2022,28(1):15-23.
GU A T, TAN W Y, LI Z Y, et al. Preparation of Ag-MMOFs composite and its degradation properties on nitrophenol[J].China Powder Science and Technology,2022,28(1):15-23.
[15]LIU Q, LOW Z X, LI L X, et al. ZIF-8/Zn2GeO4 nanorods with an enhanced CO2 adsorption property in an aqueous medium for photocatalytic synthesis of liquid fuel [J].Journal of Materials Chemistry A,2013,1(38):11563-11569.
[16]CHEN J Y, GAO Q H, ZHANG X M, et al. Nanometer mixed-valence silver oxide enhancing adsorption of ZIF-8 for removal of iodide in solution [J].Science of the Total Environment,2019,646:634-644.
[17]LI H L, LI Y, LI B L, et al. Highly selective anchoring silver nanoclusters on MOF-SOF heterostructured framework for efficient adsorption of radioactive iodine from aqueous solution [J].Chemosphere,2020,252:126448.
[18]DEL R M, VILLAR M, QUESADA S, et al. Silver-functionalized UiO-66 metal organic framework coated 3D printed device for the removal of radioactive iodine from wastewaters [J].Applied Materials Today,2021,24:101130.
[19]TAUANOV Z, INGLEZAKIS V J. Removal of iodide from water using silver nanoparticles-impregnated synthetic zeolites[J].Science of the Total Environment,2019,682:259-270.
[20]QI B B, LIU Y, ZHENG T, et al. Highly efficient capture of iodine by Cu-MIL-101[J].Journal of Solid State Chemistry,2018,258:49-55.
[21]朱玉琦,陈凯伟,张佳莉,等. 以ZIF-8为模板的Cu-Zn@C制备与吸附性能[J].中国粉体技术,2022,28(3):50-58.
ZHU Y Q, CHEN K W, ZHANG J L, et al. Preparation and adsorption properties of Cu-Zn@C with ZIF-8 as template [J].China Powder Science and Technology,2022,28(3):50-58.
[22]GONG C H, LI Z Y, CHEN K W, et al. Synthesis and characterization of Ag@Cu-based MOFs as efficient adsorbents for iodine anions removal from aqueous solutions [J].Journal of Environmental Radioactivity,2023,265:107211.
[23]鲍斌,顾傲天,陈九玉,等. 热解Cu-BTC衍生制备Ag@CuO复合材料[J].中国粉体技术,2022,28(6):21-30.
BAO B, GU A T, CHEN J Y, et al. Preparation of Ag@CuO composites by pyrolytically derivatization of Cu-BTC [J].China Powder Science and Technology,2022,28(6):21-30.
[24]YADOLLAHI M, HAMADI H, NOBAKHT V. Capture of iodine in solution and vapor phases by newly synthesized andcharacterized encapsulated Cu2O nanoparticles into the TMU-17-NH2 MOF [J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2020,399:122872.
[25]LI M L, WANG X P, ZHANG J, et al. Cu-loaded MOF-303 for iodine adsorption: the roles of Cu species and pyrazole ligands [J].Applied Surface Science,2023,619:156819.
[26]XIONG Y, ZHANG P, REN W J, et al. Rapid and selective removal of radioactive iodide ions from wastewater via bismuth-based metal-organic frameworks [J].Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering,2024,12(1):111906.
[27]WANG Z W, CHEN K W, GU A T, et al. Adsorption performance study of bismuth-doped ZIF-8 composites on radioactive iodine in the vapor and liquid phases [J].Journal of Solid State Chemistry,2023,325:124186.
[28]CHEN X J, WANG P, ZHANG Z W, et al. Bi2S3-CoS@C core-shell structure derived from ZIF-67 as anodes for high performance lithium-ion batteries [J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2020,844:156008.
[29]ZOU H, GUO J B, SONG M X, et al. Bi2S3-reduced graphene oxide composite for gaseous radioiodine capture and its immobilization within glass composite material [J].Progress in Nuclear Energy,2021,135:103705.
[30]CHEN K W, WANG P, GU A T, et al. Core-shell Bi2S3 nanorods loaded ZIF-8 nanocomposites for efficient and reversible capture of radioactive iodine [J].Microporous and Mesoporous Materials,2022,339:111983.
[31]CHEN K W, GU A T, ZHOU X Yet al. Core-shell structured Bi2S3-ZnS@C derived from ZIF-8 for efficient capture and reliable storage of volatile radioactive iodine [J].Separation and Purification Technology,2023,322:124380.
[32]HAO Y X, TIAN Z J, LIU C Y, et al. Recent advances in the removal of radioactive iodine by bismuth-based materials[J].Frontiers in Chemistry,2023,11:1122484.
[33]TANG P H, SO P B, LEE K R, et al. Metal organic framework-polyethersulfone composite membrane for iodine capture[J].Polymers,2020,12(10):2309.
[34]MIENSAH E D, CHEN J Y, GU A T, et al. Sonicated zeolitic imidazolate framework-8 derived nanoporous carbon for efficient capture and reversible storage of radioiodine [J].Journal of Solid State Chemistry,2021,299:122218.
[35]WANG Z, HE Y, ZHU L, et al. Natural porous wood decorated with ZIF-8 for high efficient iodine capture [J].Materials Chemistry and Physics,2021,258:123964.
[36]CHEN J Y, GU A T, MIENSAH E D, et al. Cu-Zn bimetal ZIFs derived nanowhisker zero-valent copper decorated ZnO nanocomposites induced oxygen activation for high-efficiency iodide elimination [J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2021,416:126097.
[37]CHEN J Y, WANG P, GONG C H, et al. Bimetal ZIFs-derived Cu0 embedded in nitrogen-doped carbon framework activation of molecular oxygen for efficient iodide elimination[J].Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering,2024,12(2):112235.
[38]XU L Y, ZHENG Q, WANG Y Y, et al. A pillared double-wall metal-organic framework adsorption membrane for the efficient removal of iodine from solution [J].Separation and Purification Technology,2021,274:118436.
[39]WANG X, MA S G, CHEN B H, et al. Swelling acidic poly(ionic liquid)s as efficient catalysts for the esterification of cyclohexene and formic acid [J].Green Energy and Environment,2020,5(2):138-146.
[40]LI Y L, LI Z Y, LI R P, et al. Highly efficient triiodide ion adsorption from water by ionic liquid hybrid metal-organic frameworks [J].Journal of Molecular Liquids,2023,370:121009.
[41]WANG L Y, LI T, DONG X T, et al. Thiophene-based MOFs for iodine capture: effect of pore structures and interaction mechanism [J].Chemical Engineering Journal,2021,425:130578.
[42]YAO M S, XIU J W, HUANG Q Q, et al. Van der Waals heterostructured MOF-on-MOF thin films: cascading functionality to realize advanced chemiresistive sensing[J].Angewandte Chemie (International Edition in English),2019,58(42):14915-14919.
[43]LIU L S, CHEN L F, THUMMAVICHAI K, et al. Amino-functionalized MOF-on-MOF nano complexes composed for radioactive-iodine efficient adsorption [J].Chemical Engineering Journal,2023,474:145858.
[44]TONG D Y, ZHAO Y L, CHEN Z C, et al. A systematic first-principles study of volatile iodine adsorption onto zeolitic imidazolate frameworks [J].Microporous and Mesoporous Materials,2021,317:111017.
[45]CHEBBI M, AZAMBRE B, CANTREL L, et al. Influence of structural, textural and chemical parameters of silver zeolites on the retention of methyl iodide [J].Microporous and Mesoporous Materials,2017,244:137-150.
[46]LIU S, ZENG Y Y, ZHANG A, et al. Efficient capture of radioactive iodine by ZIF-8 derived porous carbon [J].Journal of Environmental Radioactivity,2022,249:106895.
[47]MIENSAH E D, GU A T, KOKULOKU L T J, et al. Strategies for radioiodine capture by metal organic frameworks and their derived materials [J].Microporous and Mesoporous Materials,2022,341:112041.
[48]ANDRADE P H M, HENRY N, VOLKRINGEr C, et al. Iodine uptake by Zr-/Hf-based UiO-66 materials: the influence of metal substitution on iodine evolution[J].ACS Applied Materials and Interfaces,2022,14(26):29916-29933.
[49]LIANG J, TAN H, LIU J, et al. Combined experimental and theoretical studies on iodine capture of Zr-based metalorganic frameworks: effect of N-functionalization and adsorption mechanism [J].Materials Today Sustainability,2023,24:100574.
[50]SAVA D F, RODRIGUEZ M A, CHAPMAN K W, et al. Capture of volatile iodine, a gaseous fission product, by zeolitic imidazolate framework-8[J].Journal of the American Chemical Society,2011,133(32):12398-12401.