ISSN 1008-5548

CN 37-1316/TU

2024年30卷  第4期
<返回第4期

高掺量粉煤灰对水泥稳定煤矸石基层性能影响

Effect of replacing aggregate with fly ash on performance of cement⁃stabilized coal gangue base


张博杰1,俞 莉1,张东生2,张文博1,杨秋宁1

(1. 宁夏大学 土木与水利工程学院, 银川 750021;2. Department of Civil Engineering,KU Leuven,Bruges 8200,Belgium)


引用格式:

张博杰,俞莉,张东生,等. 高掺量粉煤灰对水泥稳定煤矸石基层性能影响[J]. 中国粉体技术,2024,30(4):43-50.

ZHANG B J, YU L, ZHANG D S, et al. Effect of replacing aggregate with fly ash on performance of cement - stabilized coal gangue base[J]. China Powder Science and Technology,2024,30(4):43−50.

DOI:10.13732/j.issn.1008-5548.2024.04.004

收稿日期:2024-04-08,修回日期:2024-05-29,上线日期:2024-06-26。

基金项目:国家自然科学基金项目,编号:51768058 ;宁夏回族自治区重点研发计划项目,编号:2021BEE03004

第一作者简介:张博杰(1999-),男,硕士生,研究方向为道路工程材料。E-mail:214170837@qq.com

通信作者简介:杨秋宁(1972-),女,教授,博士,博士生导师,研究方向为工业固废生态化利用。E-mail:yangqn@nxu.edu.cn


摘要:【目的】 为提高粉煤灰和煤矸石的利用率、减少天然碎石的开采,研究高掺量粉煤灰对水泥稳定煤矸石基层性能的增强机制,为高掺量粉煤灰在水泥稳定煤矸石基层中的应用提供理论依据。【方法】 用煤矸石全部替代天然碎石作为骨料、并掺入适量粉煤灰替代骨料,制备水泥稳定煤矸石基层混合料;通过无侧限抗压试验、劈裂试验、抗压回弹模量试验、水稳定性试验、冻融试验研究混合料的力学性能和耐久性能;研究不同粉煤灰掺量(质量分数)下混合料的强度形成机制。【结果】 粉煤灰质量分数为4%、8%时,水泥与粉煤灰发生火山灰效应,生成新的水化产物填充胶凝材料内部孔隙,提高了混合料的力学性能;粉煤灰质量分数为12%时,混合料的抗压回弹模量最大,荷载作用下混合料的变形量最小;粉煤灰掺量为16%时,粉煤灰在混合料中的微集料效应充分发挥,28 d龄期无侧限抗压强度和劈裂强度有明显提升,但抗压回弹模量减小。【结论】 在不同粉煤灰掺量下,随着粉煤灰掺量的增加,混合料的无侧限抗压强度、劈裂强度逐渐增大,抗压回弹模量先增大后减小;粉煤灰掺入后,混合料的水稳定性能和抗冻性能略有降低。

关键词:煤矸石;粉煤灰;力学性能;耐久性

Abstract

Objective With the global emphasis on environmental protection and resource conservation, improving the utilization rate of industrial waste and reducing the exploitation of natural resources have become research hotspots. Fly ash and coal gangue are the major wastes from thermal power generation and coal mining processes. Their large-scale accumulation not only occupies valuable land resources, but also pollutes the environment. Therefore, this study aims to explore the enhancement mechanism of high-content fly ash on the performance of cement-stabilized coal gangue base. It provides a new way for the effective utilization of industrial waste while reducing the exploitation of natural gravel, thereby achieving the dual goals of environmental protection and resource conservation.

Method In this study, high-quality coal gangue was selected as the aggregate to replace traditional natural gravel. Appropriate amounts of cement were selected as the bonding material, and different proportions of fly ash (4%,8%,12%,16%) were mixed. Through accurate calculations and optimized design, the composition of the mixture with different proportions was determined. To evaluate the mechanical properties of the mixture, unconfined compressive strength tests, splitting tests, and compressive rebound modulus tests were carried out. These tests comprehensively reflected the key mechanical indicators of the mixture such as compressive strength, splitting strength, and elastic modulus. To evaluate the durability of the mixture, water stability tests and freeze-thaw tests were carried out. The water stability tests simulated the performance changes of the mixture under water immersion, while the freeze-thaw test simulated the performance changes after freeze-thaw cycles in cold areas. The study also discussed the strength formation mechanisms of mixture with different fly ash content.

Result When fly ash was added to the cement at a content of 4% and 8%, a pozzolanic reaction occurred between the cement and fly ash, producing new hydration products. These newly generated hydration products were very fine and could effectively penetrate into the internal pores of the binding materials, serving to fill and reinforce them. This filling not only enhanced the compactness of the mixture, but also significantly improved its overall strength, providing a more stable foundation for construction. As the fly ash content further increased to 12%, the properties of the mixture changed significantly. Under external loads,the mixture showed excellent deformation resistance, with the deformation amount reaching its minimum. This indicated that at a specific fly ash content, the stability of the mixture was significantly improved, enabling it to withstand greater external pressure and changes. When the fly ash content increased to 16%, the micro-aggregate effect of fly ash began to show its unique advantages. This effect ensured that the fly ash particles were more evenly distributed in the mixture, enhancing their cohesion and thereby greatly improving the mechanical properties of the mixture. Experimental data showed that at this content level, the unconfined compressive strength and splitting strength of the mixture were significantly improved after 28 days of curing.

Conclusion This study showed that with the increase of fly ash content, the unconfined compressive strength and splitting strength of the cement-stabilized coal gangue base mixture gradually increased, while the compressive rebound modulus first increased and then decreased. This indicated that an appropriate amount of fly ash can improve the mechanical properties of the mixture, but an excessive content may lead to a decline in its performance. In addition, although the incorporation of fly ash slightly reduced the water stability and frost resistance of the mixture, it still met the overall engineering requirements. By analyzing the hydration reactions and microstructural changes of the mixture, it was found that the addition of fly ash promoted the hydration reaction of the cement, generating more hydration products. These hydration products filled the gaps between aggregates and improved the compactness and strength of the mixture. Moreover, the addition of fly ash also improved the pore structure of the mixture and reduced the number of large and interconnected pores. Therefore, the application of high-content fly ash in cement-stabilized coal gangue base has broad prospects. It not only increases the utilization rate of industrial waste and reduces the exploitation of natural resources, but also provides high-performance building materials for road engineering and other fields.

Keywords:coal gangue; fly ash; mechanical property; durability


参考文献(References)

[1]DONRAK J. Environmental assessment of cement stabilized marginal lateritic soil/melamine debris blends for pavement applications [J]. Environmental Geotechnics,2019:1-7.

[2]韩伟. 半刚性基层在公路工程中的应用[J]. 交通世界,2021(24):120-121.HAN W. Application of semi-rigid base in highway engineering [J]. Traffic World,2021(24):120-121.

[3]MARKOVIC J B, MARINKOVIC A D, SAVI J Z, et al. Risk evaluation of pollutants emission from coal and coal waste combustion plants and environmental impact of fly ash landfilling [J]. Toxics,2023,11(4):396.

[4]李启辉. 煤矸石的性质及综合利用研究进展[J]. 应用化工,2023,52(5):1576-1581.LI Q H. Research progress on properties and comprehensive utilization of coal gangue [J]. Applied Chemical Industry,2023,52(5):1576-1581.

[5]ZHENG Q W, ZHOU Y, LIU X, et al. Environmental hazards and comprehensive utilization of solid waste coal gangue [J].Progress in Natural Science: Materials International,2024,34(2):223-239.

[6]WANG H, CHEN Z W, ZHAO M, et al. Integrated utilization of coal gangue for synthesis of β-Sialon multiphase ceramicmaterials [J]. Ceramics International,2023,49(7):11275-11284.

[7]LI J Y, WANG J M. Comprehensive utilization and environmental risks of coal gangue: a review [J]. Journal of CleanerProduction,2019,239:117946.

[8]YU Y G, GUNASEKARA C, ELAKNESWARAN Y, et al. Unified hydration model for multi-blend fly ash cementitious systems of wide-range replacement rates [J]. Cement and Concrete Research,2024,180:107487.

[9]WANG L L, XU X B, ZHANG Q S, et al. Performance optimization of cement-fly ash grouting material based on response surface methodology [J]. Materials Science Forum,2021,6187:337-344.

[10]程银银,李宏波,康鑫睿,等 . 水泥和粉煤灰稳定钢渣-砼再生碎石路基混合料的制备及其性能[J]. 中国粉体技术,2023,29(4):11-21.CHENG Y Y, LI H B, KANG X R, et al. Preparation and properties of cement and fly ash stabilized steel slag-concrete recycled macadam subgrade mixture [J]. China Powder Science and Technology,2023,29(4):11-21.

[11]KUMAR S, SINGH D. Transforming waste into sustainable solution: physicochemical and geotechnical evaluation of cement stabilized municipal solid waste incinerator bottom ash for geoenvironmental applications [J]. Process Safety and Environmental Protection,2023,176:685-695.

[12]韩俊俊. 基于路用性能的煤矸石混合料力学特性试验研究[D]. 阜新:辽宁工程技术大学,2016. HAN J J. Experimental study on mechanical properties of coal gangue mixture based on road performance[D]. Fuxin: Liaoning University of Engineering Technology,2016.

[13]DING Y F, LI H B, ZHANG H B, et al. Shrinkage and durability of waste brick and recycled concrete aggregate stabilized by cement and fly ash [J]. Materials,2022,15(10):3684-3684.

[14]SHI X, YANG P, LI L, et al. Strength and microscopic pore structure characterization of cement-fly ash stabilized organic soil under freeze-thaw cycles [J]. Construction and Building Materials,2024,420:135635.

[15]NISRINE E F, HASSAN E, OMAR S, et al. Rheology, calorimetry and electrical conductivity related-properties for monitoring the dissolution and precipitation process of cement-fly ash mixtures [J]. Powder Technology,2022,411:117937.

[16]JOSE A, MURALI K J, ROBINSON R G. Mechanical response of cement-stabilized pond ash during repeated loading based on shakedown concept [J]. International Journal of Geomechanics,2024,24(3):04024010.

[17]AHMED Z A , HASSAN A. Prediction model of elastic modulus for granular road bases [J]. Sustainable Development Research,2020,2(1):35.

[18]HAN B Y, LING J M, XIANG S, et al. Resilient interface shear modulus for characterizing shear properties of pavement base materials[J]. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering,2018,30(12):04018333.

[19]交通运输部公路科学研究院. 公路路面基层施工技术细则: JTG/T F20—2015[S]. 北京:人民交通出版社,2015. Institute of Highway Science,Ministry of Transport. Technical specification for highway pavement base construction: JTG/TF20—2015[S]. Beijing: People’s Communications Press,2015.

[20]交通运输部公路科学研究院. 公路工程无机结合料稳定材料试验规程: JTG 3441—2024[S]. 北京:人民交通出版社,2024. Institute of Highway Science, Ministry of Transport. Test specification for inorganic binder stabilized materials in highway engineering: JTG 3441—2024[S]. Beijing: People’s Communications Press,2024.

[21]何蓓,张吾渝,童国庆,等. 粉煤灰地聚物的抗压强度及微观结构[J]. 中国粉体技术,2023,29(2):38-46.HE B, ZHANG W Y, TONG G Q, et al. Compressive strength and microstructure of fly ash geopolymer [J]. China PowderScience and Technology,2023,29(2):38-46.